The Council of Europe on Monday (9 October) awarded its top rights prize to jailed Turkish philanthropist Osman Kavala, who has come under repeated attack from President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.
The decision to give the annual Václav Havel prize to Kavala drew an angry response from Ankara, but was cheered on by groups that have long expressed worries about Turkey’s deteriorating human rights record under Erdoğan.
Kavala, 66, faced alternating charges that have ranged from espionage and financing the 2013 protests to taking part in a failed 2016 coup against Erdoğan.
He was arrested in October 2017 and sentenced to life in 2022 for allegedly trying to topple Erdoğan’s government.
“I’m very sad he cannot be with us to receive this prize, this meaningful prize,” his wife, Ayse Bugra Kavala, said, accepting the award from Tiny Kox, president of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe.
In a letter written from prison, read out by his wife, Kavala said he was honoured by the decision, and dedicated the prize to his “fellow citizens unlawfully kept in prison”.
But in a statement issued late Monday, the Turkish foreign ministry condemned the “unacceptable” award.
“Giving the award to a person who has a final conviction is an extension of attempts to politicise the law,” the Turkish ministry said, accusing the rights body of pursuing a “political agenda”.
Infringement proceedings
The Council of Europe said Kavala had supported several civil society organisations since the 1990s and that the moves against him were aimed at gagging critics and stifling dissent.
Turkey’s refusal to abide by European Court of Human Rights rulings to immediately release Kavala have torn at Ankara’s relations with Western allies.
The Council of Europe has launched infringement proceedings against Turkey over its treatment of Kavala.
That could potentially see Ankara expelled from the continent’s leading human rights organisation.
Critics say it also highlights the deterioration of Turkey’s rights record in the second decade of Erdoğan’s rule.
Turkey’s supreme court last month upheld Kavala’s conviction and life imprisonment on the charge of attempting to overthrow Erdoğan’s government during large-scale protests in 2013.
Kavala, who was born in France and graduated with a degree in economics from the University of Manchester in Britain, is not eligible for parole or able to appeal.
He was detained six years ago and acquitted in February 2020 of involvement in the 2013 protests or the 2016 coup.
But he was immediately rearrested and charged with espionage. The court then brought new charges that included ones he had already been cleared of in the first trial.
‘I will stay long’
Kavala said last month that the decision by the top appeals court to uphold his life sentence disregarded law and human life.
European officials and human rights activists condemned the confirmation of Kavala’s sentence.
The decision “further increases the concerns of the European Union regarding the Turkish Judiciary’s adherence to international and European standards,” Peter Stano, spokesman for the EU’s top diplomat Josep Borrell, said at the time.
Last month the European Union’s enlargement commissioner told candidate nation Turkey to address issues around democracy and the rule of law if it wants to boost its drive to join the bloc.
Enis Berberoğlu, an opposition lawmaker who has served time in prison, visited Kavala after the ruling was issued.
“(Kavala) told me he saw the court decision on television… while writing a letter,” Berberoglu told AFP.
“When he was writing ‘if I had to stay here longer’ … he saw the flash on TV and wrote in the letter ‘I think I will stay long’”, the lawmaker said.
Berberoğlu said Kavala’s reaction to the ruling was: “This decision is a result of an understanding that does not value law or human life”.
But the lawmaker noted: “I saw him in good morale.”
Turkey’s opposition chief Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu paid his first visit to Kavala on Friday, saying he wanted “to make injustice more visible”.
“No one should be judged for their thoughts,” Turkish media quoted Kılıçdaroğlu as saying outside Kavala’s jail.
Kavala was one of tens of thousands of Turks who were either jailed or fired from their jobs in purges that followed a bloody coup attempt against Erdoğan in 2016.
Source: Euractiv